Enemy (2014) Movie Review

Double dose of Jake Gyllenhaal aka Handsome McBeardy-Face

How can we really know who we are? Are we everything we perceive ourselves to be, or simply different figments of an unrealized whole? That is the driving force behind Denis Villeneuve's film Enemy, a slow-paced, mind bending, character study into a man who has found his doppelganger. Adam Bell (Jake Gyllenhaal) is a disgruntled, lonely professor in Toronto, who goes about the same routine daily. Teach, grade papers, get drunk, and have sex with his girlfriend Mary (Melanie Laurent). One day, at the recommendation of a colleague, Adam rents a movie, and seemingly spots himself in the movie. Confused, he searches and finds out there is an actor named Anthony St. Claire, who looks and sounds identical to him. From there, Adam begins to obsess over Anthony, taking himself down a path of self destruction. Or is he?

While the movie makes you think and try to solve the mystery behind the characters, it is squarely placed on the handsome shoulders of Jake Gyllenhaal to carry the film. And carry it he does. Playing the double roles of Anthony and Adam, Gyllenhaal brings a subtly and nuance to both performances that is undeniable. As Adam, he is refrained, quiet and constantly hinting at a deep underlying rage. And as Anthony, he is confident, arrogant and seemingly ready to blow given the opportunity. The fact that I actually forgot that it was the same actor, and simply viewed them as two characters is a testament to his performance and also helps to  give both characters a certain air of ambiguity.

Laurent is also good as Adam's girlfriend, sick of his borderline disinterest in all things except sex. Acting more as a tool to take out Adam's sexual aggression, Laurent still brings her usual level of performance, garnering the right amount of sympathy for a part most seen, and not often heard. Sarah Gadon is also very good as Anthony's pregnant wife, who seems to love Anthony to a fault, but is also tired and frustrated of his arrogance, both members of the marriage ready to start yelling at the drop of a hat. I read people complain about how their characters feel underwritten, but in the grand context of the film, it makes sense why we know what we know about the characters, and how they behave.

Being his second film of 2013, after the critically acclaimed Prisoners (also starring Jake Gyllenhaal), Denis Villeneuve is a filmmaker who is more interested in making a good, interesting film, than something accessible to everyone. Where Prisoners was hard to watch because of it's brutality and dark subject matter, Enemy is a very confusing slow burn. While he creates a sense of despair and paranoia among the characters, he excels at driving a film forward. The driving force being that, as a viewer, I genuinely had no idea what was going to happen next. So many intricate details are lightly sprinkled throughout the film, that it was on a second viewing that I began to put together more of the puzzle.

And make no mistake, the movie is a puzzle, ultimately, with no right answer. A lot of viewers enjoyment of the movie will hinder on their interpretation of the ending, and the subsequent mystery. And despite some flaws, the main one being the God-awful pacing of the film, it a film for those of use who like our films to live in a constant grey area.

Grade: B+